Get proprietary software out of schools!

I just set up a Linux computer for my young fellow so he could access Literacy Planet, a requirement of his curriculum. The install went well on an old Athlon 1900+ box of Slackware 14.1 with XFCE as the window manager. For those of you who don’t know Linux  (or GNU/LINUX) is an alternative operating system for computers, usually replacing Microsoft Windows or Apple OSX and is generally considered free software. Linux comes in many flavours, called distributions; for example Ubuntu, Linux Mint, Fedora, Arch and Slackware are all Linux distributions. They all vary in certain ways due to the individuality of their respective maintainers but they all have one thing in common; The Linux kernel.

Free software isn’t just free as in gratis. The user is free to modify and redistribute the programs as they see fit under the terms of the appropriate licence. Free software is often referred to as Open Source. While free software is all open source, not necessarily is all open source software free software.

Of course Linux is not for everyone. People buy a computer so that it “just works” out of the box. Linux requires re-installation in most cases but there are some hardware venders that do offer Linux out of the box, the most famous being Dell. Still, most consumers will be used to either Windows or Mac and purchase accordingly.

Free software is also available for Windows and Mac computers. For example, an alternative to Microsoft Office is LibreOffice; an alternative to Internet Explorer is Firefox (disclaimer: Firefox is not entirely free software as it does contain some non-free parts, however there are 100% free spin offs of Firefox). There are many more examples covering all types of software. You don’t need to be a geek to use these program, you just need to have the desire to take back your computing power.

One of the key advantages to free software is that many eyes can look over the source code and when bugs are found they are fixed almost instantly. This also improves your security as back doors are not put in place by design. With closed source proprietary software, no body apart from the programmer and his boss know what is in the software and they decide if and when security holes and bugs are fixed.

Back to the recently formatted Slackware box.

After I set it up the login, network and a nice wallpaper and icons, I browsed to Literacy Planet and proceeded to log in to my young bloke’s pre configured account. I was greeted with a splash screen..


Looks like you don’t have the latest version of Flash Player installed.

Not to worry, you can click here to download it (it’s free!)

Gasp! WTF???

I could not believe my eyes. An “educational” site, endorsed by the school curriculum, telling me to install Flash Player because “it’s free!”… and “not to worry”. Flash Player would have to be the single most insecure, buggy piece of software in existence yet we all use it daily. What makes it worse is that there is a free (as in beer, as in speech) alternative that has been around for years now, and it is cross platform; HTML5.

Yes, I do use flash out of necessity, but it is permanently blocked and only invoked if absolutely needed. But why do programmers and their employers still insist on using it? This is lunacy. Especially when education is involved. Flash no longer supports my old Athlon 1900+ processor now anyway so I can’t install it even if I wanted to. Html5 works perfectly on that old box.

I can’t help but think that this is a political decision by the powers that be to continue supporting their “mates”. Surely educators are aware that not everybody can afford the latest and greatest and especially in this time of increased security awareness that not everybody is as gullible as to accept “she’ll be right mate! It’s free!”


4 thoughts on “Get proprietary software out of schools!

  1. not just software…. why do parents have to get ipads… seriously why not less costly alternative android devices a fraction of the cost ?:-) ?:-)


  2. Yes seems to be the only thing needful in reply to this, micko.
    Well done!
    That fox browser is loosing a grip too. However, I use what is available and have not designed and made my own PC and internet and software etc, so I am learning to accept that if I don’t want to use it that’s my choice but if I do, I ned to be happy with what so many have worked on and appreciate the amazing wonder of it all!
    I am communicating now by poking plastic buttons and somehow it appears on my sc reen and when I select send or submit my thoughts get to you. AND, I did not do anything to make it all happen, as in OS and software and much more.

    Thanks again micko. I am beginning to think that your work is the best out there. Have tried a few distro’s and pups over the years and of course used some windows stuff but for speed and helpfulness and a great feeling as well, puppy is best and I am becoming more and more a slocko adict!




  3. At my school, I’m both a teacher and tech coach. I’ve also worked at the district level on pilot projects involving putting technology into schools. I am a long-time Linux user, and I feel your pain.

    Many years ago, I lay awake dreaming of ways to convert entire school districts to Linux. Now that I’ve worked on the inside, I can tell you that there is no conspiracy. There is just ignorance. And, it’s understandable.

    Technology is run by the IT department, itself based upon commercially-sold set of software. There just isn’t enough people familiar with Linux in these large-staffed departments. Many employees pre-date the advent of Windows. These are employees trained in Microsoft. To re-staff or re-train entire IT departments would be … difficult 🙂

    Given that Windows is the standard OS, we now look to applying apps in education. Choices are based upon what’s being used elsewhere successfully. No one wants to purchase something unproven. The big players in education apps are a mixed bag of old and new. The decision makers aren’t concerned with Flash or HTML5; they want to know if the app is useful, popular, effective. It’s not computer geeks picking apps but teachers and education leaders. Just as mechanics don’t pick the company fleet.

    Attend large tech-in-education conferences and you’ll be hard pressed to find talk on FLASH or HTML5. It’s teachers sharing best uses with other teachers while developers showcase their apps and what they can do, not how they’re run.

    Love your Linux.. and I use it; but when many teachers are unfamiliar with opening a new browser tab or students unwilling to learn basics of the internet (give them a URL and instead of typing it in an address bar, they’ll Google it), you have a hard enough time selling anyone the idea of using the tech in class let alone something called Linux–or Slacko!

    That’s why iPads are popular–familiar icons and such. However, in education, it matters not the app or tool but the use of it. For that, a teacher with a sound pedagogy and a lousy app will likely be more effective than the best software used as hand-out photocopier. Problem is, from my vantage point, the masters of teaching are usually not as computer dedicated as, say, masters of software.

    And there it is.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s